Court Decisions › Americas (requested by Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay)
Advisory Opinion OC-4/84 (proposed amendments to the naturalization provisions of the Constitution of Costa Rica)
Inter-American Court of Human Rights · Americas (requested by Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay) · 1984 · Regional court or body
Citation: OC-4/84, requested by Costa Rica
Type of case: Constitutional and human rights
Outcome: Outcome to be confirmed
Unchecked candidate. This decision has been located in an official or free law database but has not yet been read and written up. The summary below describes the subject only.
Subject
Whether stricter naturalization rules for some foreigners, and different rules for foreign wives and husbands, are compatible with equality before the law. The Court accepted some distinctions as reasonable but found the sex-based difference discriminatory.
Pokok perkara
Apakah aturan naturalisasi yang lebih ketat bagi sebagian orang asing, dan aturan yang berbeda bagi istri dan suami asing, sesuai dengan persamaan di depan hukum. Mahkamah menerima sebagian pembedaan sebagai wajar, tetapi menilai pembedaan berdasarkan jenis kelamin diskriminatif.
Sources
Open this decision in the interactive collection (compare, filter, Indonesian view, downloads).
Cite as: Institute for Migrant Rights (2026), Migration Jurisprudence from the South: Court Decisions, version 0.1, https://theimr.org/court-decisions/d/c-iact-oc-4-1984/. This page summarizes a court decision for research and advocacy; it is not legal advice.
More decisions from Americas (requested by Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay)
- Advisory Opinion OC-31/25 (content and scope of the right to care) Inter-American Court of Human Rights · 2025
- Advisory Opinion OC-32/25 (climate emergency and human rights) Inter-American Court of Human Rights · 2025
- Advisory Opinion OC-29/22 (persons deprived of liberty) Inter-American Court of Human Rights · 2022
- Advisory Opinion OC-27/21 (freedom of association, collective bargaining and the right to strike, with a gender perspective) Inter-American Court of Human Rights · 2021
- Advisory Opinion OC-21/14 (children in migration) Inter-American Court of Human Rights · 2014
